Freedom 17 vs Nomad 17, which is easiest to build for an absolute novice?

[JohnJ]

Hello,

between the Freedom 17 and the Nomad 17, which would be the easier canoe to build for an absolute beginner woodworker? Both models fit our canoeing profile.

And, if that beginner canoe builder was going to ask for one tool for Christmas, what would be the most useful?

Thanks in advance for any input.
JohnJ

[Patricks Dad]

I've built multiple Freedom design. I have not built a Nomad. But looking at the design of Nomad, I see that it has more curve of the sheerline and thus will require a bit more work to build. I love the Freedom 17. It's a wonderful craft and easy to build.

As for a single tool to ask for, that's a hard question. The tool you need at the moment is the one that is the most valuable. But I do an awful lot of sanding so I guess if I would have to pick one tool, it would be a good random orbital sander with a good connection to a shop vac.

A decent block plane is also an excellent gift idea.

[Jim Dodd]

I agree with Randy on his hull choice.

As for tools ?
So many come to mind, so I will a list a few of my favorites .
A Shinto Saw Rasp. ( You can buy just the rasp, without the handle ) my preferred method of use.
A Quality Japanese Pull saw. No Stanley junk !
If you are using staples ? A Bostich /Stanly staple puller.
Arrow makes a durable stapler, at a reasonable price, takes T50 staples.

Those are my hand tool favorites. My power tools.
A Skilsaw with a 15 amp motor for cutting strips.
A Freud Diablo 7 1/4 " 24 T Construction blade for the Skilsaw.
A Bosch 5" ROS with a variable speed.

Tell Santa, Hi for Me !

Jim